MétroLine 1

ExtensionChâteau de Vincennes < > Val de Fontenay

When and how will a variant be chosen?

Published on

The choice of the variant (whether in the Bois de Vincennes sector or the rear station beyond Val de Fontenay and the train breakdown centre) will take into account, among other things, the contributions collected during the consultation: this is why it is important to participate. At the end of the consultation, the guarantors have one month to publish their report, then Île-de-France Mobilité, (co-owner with the RATP and leading the preliminary consultation), two months to respond. In this response to the guarantors' assessment, Île-de-France Mobilités will indicate whether the project is going ahead and could position itself in favour of a variant. This subject will then be explored in greater depth during the studies, in continuous consultation. The choice of variants would in any case be made before the public inquiry, currently planned for 2028.

To compare the variants, multi-criteria analyses can be found in the complete consultation file on the following pages:

  • 187-188 (variants of insertion in the Bois de Vincennes sector),
  • 208-209 (alternative locations of the Val de Fontenay rear station and the train breakdown centre),
  • 215 (integration scenarios for the Val de Fontenay resort).

Concerning the comparison of costs: at this stage, the variants are compared in order of magnitude, to find out whether cost is a discriminating criterion. For example, variant C reuses an existing infrastructure under the Bois de Vincennes for the train breakdown centre: it would be less expensive, but raises other issues, particularly related to wood.

> Consult the schedule of studies in the consultation file in Chapter 1 p.18-21, Chapter 5 p.98-99